Italy fines Meta €805m over access to Android users’ photo galleries
The Italian privacy regulator says Facebook accessed photographs, videos and metadata without specific, informed consent, potentially affecting around 20 million Android users. Meta disputes the decision and plans to appeal.
Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million ($887 million) over Facebook’s access to photographs, videos and related metadata stored on Android users’ smartphones without specific consent or adequate disclosure. The decision concerns a Facebook feature that suggests images from users’ phone galleries as potential material for posts.
The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as the Garante, announced the penalty on 14 November after finding that Facebook’s Android application did not adequately explain that enabling certain app functions also authorised access to users’ photo galleries. The regulator estimated that around 20 million Android users in Italy could have been affected.
The decision has attracted international scrutiny because of the size of the penalty and its implications for how technology companies obtain permission to access personal information stored on mobile devices. The Associated Press, in its report on the €805 million penalty, said the regulator found that the relevant feature was enabled by default and relied on a single permission covering several different app functions.
Meta said it strongly disagreed with the regulator’s assessment and considered the fine disproportionate. A company spokesperson told Reuters that the feature helped people share photographs and videos and required users to grant permission through their device settings. The company said it would appeal the decision, according to Reuters’ coverage of the case.
The case centres on a feature called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook”, which has been available since 2023. It suggests photographs and videos from a user’s phone gallery while they browse Facebook, offering them as potential material to share on the platform.
According to the Garante, Facebook requested access to the gallery through a single authorisation covering the entire application and several functions with different purposes. The permission request was preceded by a generic notice about enabling other features, which the regulator said did not clearly explain that users were also authorising gallery suggestions.
The authority also found that the feature was enabled by default. Once the broader permission was granted, the application could access the device’s photo archive, including associated metadata, without users necessarily understanding the specific purpose of that access.
The distinction is important because permission to use one function does not automatically demonstrate that a person has knowingly agreed to another function involving access to a substantial collection of private information.
The Garante’s investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre. It also involved a technical assessment conducted by the authority. Its findings were published in an official statement on 14 November, available through the regulator’s original decision announcement.
The regulator based its decision on Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive. The provision protects information stored on users’ devices and requires free and informed consent before applications access that information, subject to applicable legal exceptions.
The Garante emphasised that smartphones form part of an individual’s private sphere. Consequently, access to information stored on a device requires appropriate consent even where the regulator has not established that the information was transmitted elsewhere or that a specific financial or personal harm occurred.
The authority also rejected Meta’s objection that the matter should fall under the jurisdiction of Ireland’s data protection regulator, where the company has its European headquarters. It said the ePrivacy framework does not provide the same one-stop-shop mechanism that applies to many cases under the General Data Protection Regulation.
In determining the penalty, the Garante considered the number of people potentially affected, the duration of the infringement, an earlier regulatory measure involving the company in 2019 and what it described as Meta’s limited cooperation during the investigation. It also considered changes introduced by the company after the complaint, although it regarded those measures as late and limited.
The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover, according to the regulator. Reuters and other international outlets reported the equivalent amount as approximately $887 million.
The financial penalty is accompanied by requirements intended to change how Facebook obtains permission for the gallery-suggestion feature.
Within 60 days, Meta must seek consent through a separate and specific request explaining the purpose of the feature, the fact that it requires access to the phone’s gallery and how users can disable it. The company must also keep the feature switched off by default, including for users who previously granted the broader application permission.
The regulator has set additional reporting deadlines. Meta must inform the authority within 30 days about the steps it has initiated and report within 90 days on the measures it has adopted.
These requirements go beyond simply changing the wording of a permission notice. They seek to ensure that users understand which feature is requesting access, what information it can reach and how to refuse or withdraw that access.
The case therefore places the design of consent mechanisms at the centre of the regulatory dispute. A broad permission covering multiple functions may be technically convenient, but the regulator’s position is that it cannot replace a clear explanation and specific consent for access to personal information.
The decision should not be interpreted as a finding that Meta used the photographs to train artificial intelligence models. The Garante explicitly said that its investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used for AI training, a practice Meta denies.
The authority also reserved the right to investigate separately a newer feature launched in 2026 that allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud. That functionality was not covered by the current proceedings.
This distinction matters as technology companies increasingly introduce features that analyse personal photographs, videos and other device content. The regulatory question in this case concerns access to the gallery and the validity of consent, not a judicially established use of those materials for AI training.
The Associated Press report and Al Jazeera’s coverage also distinguish the gallery-suggestion feature from the separate question of AI training and cloud processing.
The Italian decision highlights a broader challenge for digital platforms: users frequently grant applications access to information stored on their devices without fully understanding how that access may support different features.
For technology companies, this creates a tension between making applications convenient and ensuring that users can exercise meaningful control over their personal information. A permission request that is too broad or vague may allow a platform to introduce functions without users appreciating the full extent of the access involved.
The case also demonstrates how national regulators can apply European privacy rules to the technical design of widely used applications. Although the ruling concerns Italian Android users, its implications may be relevant to discussions about consent, mobile permissions and platform accountability in other jurisdictions.
Meta’s planned appeal means the dispute may continue through the legal system. For now, however, the regulator’s decision establishes a clear requirement for the company to make gallery access more transparent and obtain separate consent for the feature.
The central issue is not whether users should be able to share photographs on social media. It is whether permission to access a private photo archive can be treated as valid when the specific purpose of that access has not been adequately explained. Italy’s regulator has concluded that, in this case, it could not.
Sources
The primary source is the Italian Data Protection Authority’s official announcement of the €805 million sanction, which sets out the legal basis, investigation findings and compliance requirements. Independent reporting includes Reuters’ account of Meta’s response and planned appeal, the Associated Press report, The Guardian’s AFP report, Al Jazeera’s coverage and The Washington Post’s report.